News 06/29/00

Special report: Quest for Fire



24 hours a day, year-round, the ancient USU heating plant keeps the flickering flames alive

 

Story by Paul Edwards
Photos by Bryce Atkins

Left: The belly of the beast

You step back to avoid the blast of super-hot air that still slams you in the face as the plant foreman swings open the 2-inch-thick, lunch-tray-sized door. The thundering fire inside throws an orange-yellow glow onto the once white-painted concrete walls.

"Pretty hot in there," yells Wallace Spring over the roar of the boiler's inferno. Spring is the foreman at Utah State University's Central Heating Plant.

Ben Berrett, the mechanical and electrical manager at USU, also moves to peer inside the rumbling boiler. He has seen it before, but there is something about the intense, yellow glow that makes you want to look again.

Just down the wooded hillside from the Haight Alumni House stands the heating plant, which appears to be nearing the end of its century of faithful service. The university is making plans to build a gas-fired steam plant and abandon the old one as it nears the point of wearing out. Berrett said the largest obstacle so far has been getting funding from the Legislature for construction.

"We finally made it to the top of the list," he said.

A comprehensive infrastructure study created by Stanley Consultants in February estimated the cost of a new plant at about $40.5 million. The Utah Legislature approved just over $9 million for the project last session.

Berrett said the university is just getting started with the planning of a new plant, which he thinks will be built northwest of the Spectrum, immediately across from 900 North Street.

Until a new plant opens, the university will continue to rely on the one that has pumped steam out to the far reaches of the Logan campus for many years. Exactly how many is a question.

"We aren't really sure," said Spring. "I have heard the year 1898 kicked around a little bit, but I'm not sure anybody really knows."

Records in the university's Special Collections at Merrill Library don't do much to clear up the question.

In 1911, the Biennial Report, a campus publication, said, "The capacity of the heating plant has been too small for the needs of the college buildings." The plant was described as old-fashioned and wasteful, and an "unecessary expense for the state." That report is the earliest document the library has that mentions the heating plant.

"The east wall is part of the old original building," said Spring.

Today the wall bows from its struggle to hold back the hillside behind it. It looks like a patchwork of cracked concrete, crumbling red-brick foundations and a number of failed attempts to resurface it with some sort of rough masonry.

"You can only guess how well that would survive an earthquake," said Berrett. "Look, you can see the old, original re-bar, or what's left of it," he said, pointing to the dimly lighted wall.

The metal that was meant to reinforce the concrete wall is now exposed, and you can see what's left of it running vertically down the wall where the concrete has broken away. It has nearly disintegrated into a rust-colored line that runs nearly to the floor before the crumbling concrete is intact enough to cover it again.

"I don't think this part of the wall even holds anything," said Spring, pointing to a corner where a child-sized piece of concrete has broken loose.

In the 1911 report is a request for the plant to be remodeled. It said, "The new plant is one of the best planned in the state, it has been argued that it may be extended to care for the university under any reasonable growth for fifty to one hundred years."

Eighty-nine years later, the university still relies on that remodeled plant. Library records show that it was remodeled again in the early 1940s, and again in the early 1960s. Each renovation brought in newer equipment and expanded the building, but the old part is still operating and the same old boilers are still in use.

The latest addition to the plant came last year, when all of its control systems were computerized. Spring said that the new controls have helped to increase the plant's efficiency, but the plant is fighting a losing battle because the equipment operated by the controls is so old. He said the plant is well maintained, but worn out from long, hard service.

The plant operates 24 hours a day, all year long. Spring said it is shut down for 10 days every summer for upkeep, but is brough back on line as quickly as possible. Many buildings require hot water or steam during the summer.

The plant heats more tham 100 buildings on campus, and more than 3.5 million square feet, said Berrett. The pipes run as far north as the Spectrum and as far south as the Ray B. West building. The Fine Arts Building is on the system, and so is Old Main. Every building on the main campus is connected to the main line that runs from the heating plant. Berrett said the main steam lines are as big a concern as the boilers themselves. They too are old and worn out.

"The new Widtsoe Building has added a huge new load to the system," said Berrett. "I don't even know if I could tell you all of the places that use steam on campus."

The plant heats all of the hot water the campus uses, and many of the air conditioners require steam to operate. Many of the science and research labs also require steam.

Berrett said he thinks it is interesting that a top-of-the-line research facility such as Widtsoe is being connected to such old technology. While research technology is upgraded, the heating process remains the same.

That heating begins deep in a coal mine in Scofield, Utah, as coal is dug up and trucked to USU. The coal is dumped through a grate in the heating plant parking lot, where it falls into a temporary storage bunker.

The underground bunker is a large, square funnel that feeds the coal onto an enclosed, screw-driven conveyor. The conveyor shuffles the coal lup to the roof of the building and loads it in another storage bunker.

>From the roof, the coal can be fed into the boilers, mixed with force-fed air and ignited. The USU plant burns 42 to 120 tons of coal a day, depending on the air temperature. That works out to about four dump truck loads a day in the summer and 10 in the winter.

The hellish heat generated by the boilers turns water into steam and sends it rushing out to campus at 220 degrees Fahrenheit. The steam is released into a network of tunnels and pipes that run everywhere below campus. Those pipes feed steam to the classroom heaters, where it condenses and is returned to the plant at 160 degrees. The plant collects the condensed steam in a yellow tank the size of a semi-trailer, called a condensate receiver.

The receiver sits about 20 feet off the plant floor and feeds the water back into another trailer-sized tank where any oxygen, acid and minerals are removed. This keeps the iron parts of the system from corroding too quickly. The water is then fed back to the boiler to begin the trip again.

"We can burn natural gas and diesel fuel if we have to," said Spring. It is necessary to have backup systems for the boilers. He said that natural gas is the No. 1 backup, but if it gets really cold outside, Questar will shut off the gas supply to save fuel for residential areas. The gas boiler had been fired recently when a visitor stopped by, creating the brilliant purple-yellow flame that could been seen when Spring opened the access door.

Spring can remember the gas being shut off only twice in his 16 years at the plant.

If the plant can't get coal and Questar shuts off the gas, Berrett said the plant could use 40,000 gallons of diesel fuel stored underground nearby.

"The problem is, 40,000 gallons will last us about one day," said Berrett. He said that the university has a stockyard on the north end of campus that can hold about 30 days' worth of coal, and it has a generator that keeps the plant running during power failures.

"We have done everything we can to keep things from freezing up on campus," said Berrett. He said the plant must keep the boilers running at all costs.

The five boilers are square iron boxes, each the size of a small house, that look like something you would see on a very large steam locomotive. They are painted bright red, but the paint has faded and the iron darkened from years of heat and daily cleaing.

"This one here is our newest boiler," said Spring, pointing to the crouching red giant at the west end of the gymnasium-sized building. It is more than 30 years old, he said.

The age of the boilers is a concern to plant operators because all of the operation and maintenance manuals that the plant has suggest that 40 years is as long as you should operate a boiler.

The plant controls its pollution levels by fine-tuning the air-fuel ratio, said Spring. As long as it is running properly, there will never be a heavy black cloud of smoke coming from the buring coal. Instead, there is usually harmless white steam above the plant.

"We have a burp once in a while," said Berrett. "The neighbors start calling really quick when that black smoke starts pouring out of the stacks."

Berrett said they usually don't have to worry about emissions, and he credits capable plant operators.

When old equipment does break down, the plant crew usually hands its own repairs. Spring said getting spare parts is always a challenge since many of the companies that built the original equipment aren't around anymore.

Most of the parts they can order come from the Great Lakes region. Those companies generally don't have parts on hand, so they have to hire a foundry to build new ones. Spring said the foundries wait until they have enough parts ordered to be worth their time to produce them.

"It takes 12 to 20 weeks to get new parts," said Spring. Spring and his crew try to keep spare parts on hand, but they are expensive. They are able to do most of the repairs because of Spring's lifelong experience with steam boilers.

"We don't have anyone here with a degree in boilers," Spring said.

Below: The interior of the plant is a maze of color-coded pipes, with green pipes for steam and yellow for water.

Bottom: The roof.

 

A View from the roof of the central heating plant.

"
Pretty hot in here.
"

--Wallace Spring

The control room houses computers that the builders of the plant could scarcely have dreamed of.

"
The new plant is one of the best planned in the state, it has been argued that it may be extended to care for the university under any reasonable growth for fifty to one hundred years.
"

--1911 report

 

 




MS
MS

Archived Months:

September 1998
October 1998

January 1999
February 1999
March 1999
April 1999
September 1999
October 1999
November 1999
December 1999

January 2000
February 2000
March 2000
April 2000
May 2000
June 2000